Blood libel 

Blood libels are sensationalized allegations that a person or group engages in human sacrifice, often accompanied by the claim that the blood of victims is used in various rituals and/or acts of cannibalism. The alleged victims are often children.

Some of the best documented cases of blood libel focus upon accusations against Jews, but many other groups have been accused throughout history, including Christians, Cathars, Carthaginians, Knights Templar, witches, Wiccans, Christian heretics, Roma, Mormons, neopagans, Native Americans, atheists and communists.

Contents

Against Jews

Fresco in St Paul's Church in Sandomierz, Poland, depicting blood libel
Fresco in St Paul's Church in Sandomierz, Poland, depicting blood libel

The first recorded instance of a blood libel against Jews was in the writings of Apion, who claimed that the Jews sacrificed Greek victims in the Temple of Jerusalem. After this, there are no existent records of the blood libel against the Jews until the 12th century legend surrounding William of Norwich, first recorded in the Peterborough Chronicle. The libel afterward became an increasingly common accusation. In many subsequent cases, antisemitic blood libels served as the basis for a blood libel cult, in which the alleged victim of human sacrifice was venerated as a Christian martyr. Many Jews were killed as a result of false blood libels, which continued into the 20th century, with the Beilis Trial in Russia and the Kielce pogrom in post-World War II Poland.

Against Christians

During the first and second centuries, some Roman commentators had various interpretations of the ritual of the Eucharist and related teachings. While celebrating the Eucharist, Christians drink red wine in response to the words "This is the blood of Christ". Propaganda arguing that the Christians literally drank blood based on their belief in transubstantiation was written and used to persecute Christians. Romans were highly suspicious of Christian adoptions of abandoned Roman babies and this was suggested as a possible source of the blood.

In the Mandaean scripture, the Ginza Rba, a purportedly Christian group called the "Minunei" are accused of it against the Jews: "They kill a Jewish child, they take his blood, they cook it in bread and they proffer it to them as food."[1]

Blood libels in the modern world

Accusations of ritual murder have gradually disappeared from mainstream Christianity, and some child martyrs have been removed from the official Catholic calendar of saints. In the modern world, only radical groups and individuals advance accusations of ritual murder and blood libels.

One claim states that physicians in the People's Republic of China who perform abortions consider the fetus a delicacy and eat it.[2] The story, reported from Hong Kong by Bruce Gilley, was investigated by Senator Jesse Helms, and gruesome artwork reminiscent of traditional depictions of blood libel was featured in several pro-life campaigns. [3] The only use for "human fetal tissue" is in the medical research field, particularly stem cell research.[4][5]

Comparison of Brown's cartoon (right) and  Goya's painting (left).
Comparison of Brown's cartoon (right) and Goya's painting (left).

Many Jewish groups were shocked in 2003 by the British newspaper The Independent's publication of a cartoon depicting Ariel Sharon eating a baby.[6] The Israeli government complained to the Press Complaints Commission that the cartoon alluded to the blood libel of Jews eating the children of Christians; Dave Brown, the author, responded that the cartoon was in fact inspired by Francisco de Goya's painting Saturn Devouring His Son and was not anti-Semitic in intent. The PCC accepted Brown's argument, stating "There is nothing inherently anti-semitic about the Goya image or about the myth of Saturn devouring his children, which has been used previously to satirise other politicians accused of sacrificing their own 'children' for political purposes".[7] The cartoon ultimately earned Brown the British Political Cartoon Society's Political Cartoon of the Year award.

Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, during his March 2006 failed bid for re-election, said communists had a history of boiling babies.[8] "I have been accused many times of saying communists eat babies," said Berlusconi at a rally of his Forza Italia party.[8] "Go and read the Black Book on Communism and you'll find that under Mao's China they didn't eat babies but they boiled them to fertilise the fields."[8] Despite Berlusconi's 2006 denial that he has ever said that 'communists eat babies,' in the 2001 campaign, Berlusconi said "I can organise a conference in which I will prove communists have really eaten babies and done even worse things.[8]

In July 2007, American Michael Yon reported that Lieutenant David Wallach, an Arabic translator, had told him an Iraqi official's allegations that Al-Qaeda in Iraq has baked a young boy and served the boy's body to his family.[9] These claims were later repeated in articles by the conservative American website World Net Daily.[10][11]

Occasionally, antisemitic accusations of ritual murder still can be found in Islamist propaganda and state-sponsored media published in a number of Muslim nations.[12]

In the 1990s, a number of publications by Russian Orthodox Church, as well as radio and TV broadcasts in Belarus revived medieval allegations of ritual murder of child saint Gavriil Belostoksky.[13] The revival of the cult was cited as a dangerous expression of antisemitism in international reports on human rights and religious freedoms[14][15][16] and were passed to the UNHCR.[17][18]

In 2002, controversial far-left Indian Christian radical Arundhati Roy, in an attempt to capitalize on anti-Hindu hysteria among Islamic extremists in India, perpetrated a blood libel that Indian Hindus forcibly kill pregnant Muslim women and abort the fetuses. The claim was debunked by Balbir Punj in a detailed article on Outlook India, where he demonstrates how Roy and her extreme left sympathizers capitalized on the hysteria to justify discrimination, bigotry and prejudice against Hindus.[19]

In 2006, Chinese nationalist Li Ao in his TV talk show, in an attempt to portray the 1950 People's Liberation Army invasion of Tibet as a humanitarian intervention, claimed that the Dalai Lama had commanded human sacrifices, asking his followers to "tear out human skin" for "some religious ceremony".[20]

See also

References

  1. ^ Ginza Rba 9.1
  2. ^ "Fetus Feast". Snopes.com (2007-02-03). Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  3. ^ Chinese Eating Fetuses: Christian Pornography
  4. ^ "Human-tissue-use". Office of Human Subjects Research, United States National Institute of Health (2000-09-20). Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  5. ^ "ETHICAL GUIDELINES FOR THE USE OF HUMAN EMBRYONIC OR FETAL TISSUE FOR EXPERIMENTAL AND CLINICAL NEUROTRANSPLANTATION AND RESEARCH". Network of European CNS Transplantation and Restoration (1996-02-21). Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  6. ^ Bunder, Leslie. ""Grotesque" cartoon award". Something Jewish. Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  7. ^ Bryne, Ciar (2003-05-22). "Independent cartoon cleared of anti-semitism", Guardian Unlimited. Retrieved on 2007-10-20. 
  8. ^ a b c d "Berlusconi's communist claims", Sydney Morning Herald (2006-03-27). Retrieved on 2007-10-20. 
  9. ^ "Baqubah Update: 05 July 2007". Michael Yon (2007-07-05). Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  10. ^ Unruh, Bob (2007-07-19). "More cases of terrorists 'baking' children cited". World Net Daily. Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  11. ^ "Report: Al-Qaida bakes little boys". World Net Daily (2007-07-13). Retrieved on 2007-10-20.
  12. ^ Examples of antisemitic accusations in the modern Muslim world:
  13. ^ "Blood Libel" Documentary Broadcast in Belarus - The Union of Councils for Soviet Jews (UCSJ) Action Alert - campaign against antisemitic programming on state TV. September 16, 1997
  14. ^ Belarus. International Religious Freedom Report 2003 Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor
  15. ^ Belarus. International Religious Freedom Report 2006 Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor
  16. ^ Annual Report on International Religious Freedom 2004
  17. ^ UNHCR - U.S. Department of State Annual Report on International Religious Freedom for 2006 - Belarus
  18. ^ UNHCR - Refworld Redirect
  19. ^ Fiddling with facts as Gujarat Burns,Outlook India[1]
  20. ^ youtube.com video, with English subtitles

Further reading

General

Jews

Case studies

External links